I believe you. I know the interview you’re talking about but that was my point. Scott thought she was done, she didn’t. She knew she wasn’t done yet so she kept writing and it ended up differently once she wrote Red and her sound started to change. I even remember him saying he had to tell her to stop writing with Red whereas with Speak now she just stopped writing on her own when it was done. It’s not that your fact is wrong it’s just more the way you worded it because you said she was going to finish it with those songs back then and changed her mind but I was just pointing out that she probably wasn’t planning on finishing it just yet at the time, that’s why she kept writing for it and ended up with the songs that are on there now. Scott just thought she was done because she already had so many songs for it. But she didn’t think so. I’m being not-picky, I know. I was just pointing that out.
I’m pretty sure she wrote it long before that. Like almost a year before. It is about Jake after all and she said she wrote it early on. I’m not even sure the shoes were a clue to be honest. She was obviously liking the color at the time anyway so that could’ve been coincidental as well. That’s why I don’t really believe the whole Roses theory just yet even though it pops up all the time. And yes, I know the song changed the direction of the album, I just don’t think she felt she was done with it that early and then decided to change it. I think she was still working on it (because it was so early on) and then it changed directions because that happens to her all the time, that’s why she usually throws out her earlier stuff, because it’s too similar to her last album and she always likes her newer stuff better so she keeps writing the whole time. That’s why we get last minute additions on every album.
Good to know, haha I don’t mean to be nit-picky I just always remember if I’ve seen something before and I think I just keep getting confused by the ones that I submitted to you that someone sent me because I remember seeing them but they’re not ones I came up with. The girl who sent them to me pointed that out to me last time I thought you posted one twice. Sometimes you do have very similar ones though, just none with the same exact wording of the same exact fact. But yeah, I just mention it when I think I’ve seen it posted before so you don’t end up with doubles. Not that anyone other than me would notice with how many facts you have up. lol There’s almost 1300!